Lets never forget Sam himself was once, um, gifted.
And in this weeks case, we see Sam put his experiences to good use.
The best part about this scenario?

Credit: Jack Rowand/The CW
Theres no response, and as Dean puts it, Im a 13-year-old girl.
Sam returns in just enough time to get caught up on the Lucifer of it all.
And as it turns out, Sams a big fan of Vince Vicente.

(Perhaps hes his hair idol?)
Just like that, Dean decides Beth, a witch, clearly killed Olivia to get the better office…
Yet, how does that explain the delivery boy who just died?
Dean:Yeah, who?
According to them, theyre upset because they liked Olivia better than Beth.
It seems Olivia was more connected to God.
Of course, that leads to them asking Sam and Dean if they know God.
And as Dean puts it, Oh yeah, were besties.
But thats not all he tells her: God didnt kill your daughter.
(Needless to say, Dean isnt the only one running short on patience in this hour.)
Once Sam wakes up, he tries to explain to Magda that shes not the devil.
Abrahams the only one to eat it before Magda intervenes and saves her brother.
However, when her brother tries to save her back, it results in his death.
(Fun fact: Moms equally as deadly with a knife as she is with rat poison.)
Sam convinces Magda to let her mother live, which results in moms arrest.
As for Magda, shes going to stay with her aunt in California.
[Insert aww here.]