Nev SchulmanandMax Josephknow shocking.
MAX:We ended up believing in ghosts.
NEV:Yeah, we ended up believing in spirits.

Credit: Pamela Littky
I mean, it changed our worldview and our sense of life after death.
That’s about as shocking as it gets.
Because in Judaism, we don’t believe in an afterlife.
NEV:So, mediums are real.
NEV:I do think that the medium episode is the most shocking.
That’s going to be tough to beat.
[But] I think Kya and Dani was also shocking.
And then it turns out that Alyx is maybe a girl in California named Danielle.
Right there on the show, they go out on a date and they kiss.
It didn’t last for very long, but that was shocking in the most pleasant way.
NEV:This was shocking.
I still think about it.
So Rod met Ebony on an Adam-for-Adam site, like a gay website for men.
NEV:And he meets a woman on there named Ebony, who’s only on there for friendship.
And then tells him that, actually, she’s a transgender woman.
And it didn’t turn into that.
So that was shocking.
In this rare case, yes.
The two were engaged on aCatfishreunion show, only to break off the engagement many months later.
NEV:Derek and Lauren!
It was shocking that Derek wound up being Derek.
MAX:That’s true.
NEV:That was like, kind of our happiest ending.They got engaged onCatfish, live.
Lucille and Kidd Cole: Season 3, Episode 4
Before Joanne the Scammer, there was Kidd Cole.
NEV:Kidd Cole was pretty wild.
[He’s] now in jail!
So he’s in jail.
That was shocking, he was just a shocking kind of sociopath character.[Ed.
note: He called in 11 threats, which is still 11 too many.]
Catfishseason 6 premieres Wednesday, March 1 at 8 p.m.